Blogroll
- Meals I Have Eaten
- Jess's New Blog
- One of Jess's Old Blogs
- The Stop Button
- Jenerator's Rant
- The Rejection Collection
- Pockets Stuffed With Notes
- The Silkie Road
- PostSecret
- Informed Comment
- Talking Points Memo
- Spoken & Heard
- Ever So Strange
- that-unsound
- Marvelous Prompts (& Responses)
- Only Words To Play
- So Misunderstood
- Acknowledge & Proceed
Profile & Email
Previous Posts
- P.S.
- downtown Bville Halloween thriller dance
- autumn last bloomers
- sending-out woes
- the most perfect kernal ever
- the best and the brightest
- from pumpkin carving party
- ghosting through
- after all these years, an abundance of my new favo...
- I'll take it
Archives
- April 2005
- May 2005
- June 2005
- July 2005
- August 2005
- September 2005
- October 2005
- November 2005
- December 2005
- January 2006
- February 2006
- March 2006
- April 2006
- May 2006
- June 2006
- July 2006
- August 2006
- September 2006
- October 2006
- November 2006
- December 2006
- January 2007
- February 2007
- March 2007
- April 2007
- May 2007
- June 2007
- July 2007
- August 2007
- September 2007
- October 2007
- November 2007
- December 2007
- January 2008
- February 2008
- March 2008
- April 2008
- May 2008
- June 2008
- July 2008
- August 2008
- September 2008
- October 2008
- November 2008
- December 2008
- January 2009
- February 2009
- March 2009
- April 2009
- May 2009
- June 2009
- July 2009
- August 2009
- September 2009
- October 2009
- November 2009
- December 2009
- January 2010
- February 2010
- March 2010
- April 2010
- May 2010
- June 2010
- July 2010
- August 2010
- September 2010
- October 2010
- November 2010
- December 2010
- January 2011
- February 2011
- March 2011
- April 2011
- May 2011
- June 2011
- July 2011
- August 2011
- September 2011
- October 2011
- November 2011
- December 2011
- January 2012
- February 2012
- March 2012
- April 2012
- May 2012
- June 2012
- July 2012
- August 2012
- September 2012
- October 2012
- November 2012
- January 2013
- March 2013
- May 2014
n. infantile pattern of suckle-swallow movement in which the tongue is placed between incisor teeth or between alveolar ridges during initial stage of swallowing (if persistent can lead to various dental abnormalities) v. [content removed due to Bush campaign to clean up the internet] n. act of nyah-nyah v. pursuing with relentless abandon the need to masticate and thrust the world into every bodily incarnation in order to transform it, via the act of salivation, into nutritive agency
Sunday, November 08, 2009
that time of the quarter, and rainbows
I'm at that stage in the quarter when the students start complaining about everything. Probably later in Fall Quarter than it is during the rest of the school year.
What I want to know: Are there any low-level comp classes that don't include this state of affairs? Are there actually jobs where people, as a whole, spend as much time noticing what they're being given as they do crapping on those who don't give 'enough'? Is this an American thing? (My ESL students always seem more confused and frustrated, but more grateful in the end when I care enough to do as much as I can... more careful to balance saying "I don't get it" with "I appreciate your time.") Why is it predominately the guy students who give me grief (unless I call them out, which I don't enjoy doing), especially as they get older? Are the female students just less forthcoming about their dissatisfaction? Do they think I am crappy too, but are just conditioned not to say it? Or maybe it's about the age difference, but if that's so, how am I supposed to cater to the intellectual necessities of those my own age (and thus capable of their own intelligent engagement) and those of children not even out of high school, all at the same time? I try to capture what might interest me, my friends, and those I respect who are different from me, but certainly I can't speak to everyone.
I can't help remembering how even a girl I dated reported 'circulating rumors' of my class being all busy-work, and useless.
How am I supposed to gauge the effectiveness of my pedagogy when I'm supposed to help students achieve really difficult tasks that have little immediate reward, but all in a short period of time? Maybe I am a bad teacher... but how would I know, for real? It's so confusing, and for awhile it's satisfying because I like the material, and I believe in the form of awareness, but then students rebel, and I find myself searching their writing for signs of movement just to determine my own worth, which is silly, I think, because their writing is their own. Their decisions, their thoughts, their attempts. Not mine.
But if they are frustrated and unsatisfied, how am I supposed to see my own involvement: as just another part of their frustrating, time consuming process, or as a well-intentioned person who comes short of providing the learnin' they need?
And I want to whine a great deal about how close, despite my two grad degrees, to the poverty belt I get paid, about having to work two other temp-jobs to earn basic money that would get me nowhere if I weren't living on my mom's property. But the truth is that the second grad degree I took was totally for me, selfish-like and in love with learning, and the first grad degree maybe only partially offset my ridiculous bachelors degree in something I didn't really want to follow (I could've made that one work, but would have had to put at least partially aside the creative part of myself, although I suspect that in the long run the diligence might have been rewarding). It's not the student's fault that I'm not clear on whether this is a professional choice or a default choice, and it's not their fault I always feel pulled in so many directions.
But how do people find it possible to work as an adjunct for so many years, when neither paid well nor respected for their service? Or attempts at service, as I often feel.
Are all jobs at least as demeaning as they are rewarding? Is it inevitable to find a majority of people willing to tell you you've not spent enough time? Is this the Truth of working? The futility, the grasps towards meaning, the anger at not enough of you being used, for what you really have to offer? When I think about it, most of life seems thankless, and it's up to me to find meaning within all that, but how do people find enough within them to care and keep on trying despite all the failure and criticism, or even sometimes compliments that pass on by because I'm tired, trying to do so much on my own (I have CR and mom behind me, sometimes others, but rarely is anyone else here, involved, which is what ultimately makes it worthwhile), and sometimes even the compliments don't register as pleasure.
I mean, I'm not talking about anything difficult, I don't think. Most people need to feel needed, a part of things, helpful, at least not ignored, wasteful, ignorable, useless. Etc.
My tutoring student today, whom I so adore, told me not to "take it personally" after I told her I was having difficulties being criticized, then went briefly over her reading/writing with her. As she walked out the door: "don't take it personally." If I were to take it impersonally, what would that look like? I mean, how would I mark the line between my contribution and theirs? How would I know if I were failing (or succeeding) if everything were to be impersonal?
I realized the other day during Artwalk, when nobody showed up except the woman who co-runs the gallery next door: meeting people happens bit by bit, and sometimes you're in the middle of feeling sorry for yourself about the past, but there in your present are the beginnings. I always feel like that here, like maybe things are about to change. Damn the cycle though, damn it for making it hard to feel anything that might be here. All I had to talk about with that women who stopped by was how both of us were trying to work with, and make, and understand, what might be here. And in the midst: I like her. So does that count towards making connections? Or is that chatting with someone in the hall?
I went out to a gathering/hoedown/bonfire/barn-concert last night. Saw the Sheila (ex-employer a la sculptor woman) and was a little weird. Flirted and skipped town like a true social fuck-up. But enjoyed myself and the trains and the rain over embers, and the long line-up of hippie food, including so much bread and hummus and line dancing you'd swear that patchouli and pot were the new underarm deodorants of humanity. Good times, and I'll refrain from making any overall commentary, other than to note that it took two glasses of red wine to get me feeling moderately comfortable in all that, even if I'm trying to be more tempered these days.
Comments:
Home
"so much bread and hummus and line dancing you'd swear that patchouli and pot were the new underarm deodorants of humanity"
this is the best line ever!
this is the best line ever!
It's always hard to be criticized. You say to yourself it doesn't matter but really it does sting a bit.
Just remember you can't please everyone....
f-em.
Just remember you can't please everyone....
f-em.
Yeah, it also tends to sting a bit more when the criticism is couched sneakily in a so-called "self reflection" where they're supposed to talk about their accomplishments, progress, and stumbling blocks, but instead talk about how confusing, rushed, garbled, and unclear all the coursework has been, so it was impossible for them to have learned anything.
I do much better when students come up to me in person, ask questions, tell me where they were confused by my lessons or handouts, and keep telling me that they're confused until they're not. Sometimes they tease me, and that too is okay with me. But criticizing back-handedly just depresses me like nothing else, maybe because I feel like it's probably what they're going to write on my student evaluations, which effects my employability.
I do much better when students come up to me in person, ask questions, tell me where they were confused by my lessons or handouts, and keep telling me that they're confused until they're not. Sometimes they tease me, and that too is okay with me. But criticizing back-handedly just depresses me like nothing else, maybe because I feel like it's probably what they're going to write on my student evaluations, which effects my employability.
Yeah, it also tends to sting a bit more when the criticism is couched sneakily in a so-called "self reflection" where they're supposed to talk about their accomplishments, progress, and stumbling blocks, but instead talk about how confusing, rushed, garbled, and unclear all the coursework has been, so it was impossible for them to have learned anything.
I do much better when students come up to me in person, ask questions, tell me where they were confused by my lessons or handouts, and keep telling me that they're confused until they're not. Sometimes they tease me, and that too is okay with me. But criticizing back-handedly just depresses me like nothing else, maybe because I feel like it's probably what they're going to write on my student evaluations, which effects my employability.
I do much better when students come up to me in person, ask questions, tell me where they were confused by my lessons or handouts, and keep telling me that they're confused until they're not. Sometimes they tease me, and that too is okay with me. But criticizing back-handedly just depresses me like nothing else, maybe because I feel like it's probably what they're going to write on my student evaluations, which effects my employability.
do you have any idea how comparable the criticism is to other instructors?? What I mean - do they have the same problems or are you making it out to be worse than it really is? (or maybe that means you just care a bit more...)
Hmmm. Well, I do know that the English teachers who teach stuff that's a bit more complex and who don't hand out all A's are probably all critiqued a bit harsher (it's expected in math, but not in English).
And I know that the self-reflections can be a very angsty moment in all classes that use them, although they also can be a great tool to see what the students are thinking about their process. I have one friend who instantly fails students on their reflections if they start griping though.
I'm sure that it's me being somewhat hypersensitive. No doubt it's partially timing (I just spent hours and hours for the little spitwads last week b/c I got hit by about 300pages of grading to do all at once), but also I do consistently get some of the same feedback... and no matter what I do to try new ways around issues of 'clarity' and 'excessive'... I still get the same feedback.
Post a Comment
And I know that the self-reflections can be a very angsty moment in all classes that use them, although they also can be a great tool to see what the students are thinking about their process. I have one friend who instantly fails students on their reflections if they start griping though.
I'm sure that it's me being somewhat hypersensitive. No doubt it's partially timing (I just spent hours and hours for the little spitwads last week b/c I got hit by about 300pages of grading to do all at once), but also I do consistently get some of the same feedback... and no matter what I do to try new ways around issues of 'clarity' and 'excessive'... I still get the same feedback.
Home